image

The Hidden Cost of Choosing the Wrong Realtor

October 07, 20255 min read

The Hidden Cost of Choosing the Wrong Realtor

When you hire a realtor, you’re not just hiring someone to unlock doors and fill out paperwork. You’re choosing the person who will stand beside you in one of the most emotional and financially significant chapters of your life. And yet, too often, people make that choice for the wrong reasons.

I’ve seen it happen more times than I can count.

An acquaintance of mine once hired an agent simply because they were “in the right circles.” They believed that popularity alone would bring the right buyer through the door. And sure enough, their house sold. From the outside, it looked like success. But when I heard them tell their story, I couldn’t help but think: so much was left on the table.

They didn’t know what questions to ask, so they assumed everything went as it should. The truth? With better positioning, stronger negotiation, and a guided process, there likely could have been more—more peace of mind, more leverage, and yes, more money in their pocket. But because that wasn’t their experience, they’ll never know what was lost.

And that’s the problem with hiring the wrong realtor: you don’t always see the costs until it’s too late.


The Invisible Costs No One Talks About

It’s not just about the commission rate or how quickly a sign goes in the yard. The real losses often show up in ways homeowners never see coming:

  • Repair Costs: Too often, sellers agree to inspection repairs they don’t actually need to do—simply because their agent didn’t know how to push back or structure the contract correctly.

  • Positioning Mistakes: Listing a home “as-is” without proper context can scare buyers away, costing you far more than the repairs themselves would have.

  • Negotiation Terms: The right terms matter just as much as the right price. Without leverage, you can end up underselling your home and overpaying for your next one.

  • Time & Stress: A chaotic, disconnected process doesn’t just cost you money—it costs you sleep, peace of mind, and the ability to enjoy what should be an exciting new chapter.


Why Connection and Communication Matter

I’ve heard heartbreaking stories from clients who came to me after hiring the wrong agent in the past. They describe feeling alone. Chaotic. Out of the loop.

And here’s what I know:
Connection and communication change everything.

When you feel heard, when you understand what’s happening, when you can see the strategy laid out in front of you—it brings peace to an otherwise uncertain process. It gives you back a sense of control.

But let me be clear: good communication means nothing if I’m not also putting more money in your pocket at the finish line. The two go hand in hand.


The Realtor I Chose to Be

When I started in real estate, I didn’t grow up with a silver spoon or a family legacy of homeownership. I grew up in apartments. I knew what it felt like to want more stability, more possibility.

My very first transaction? Selling my mom and stepdad their first home. My third? Selling my brother and sister-in-law theirs. Those experiences shaped me. They taught me that this business isn’t just about houses—it’s about people stepping into the next chapter of their lives. And I wanted to make sure every client of mine felt supported, protected, and empowered through that journey.


A Story of Partnership

Not long ago, I helped a friend sell her home. Today, she tells everyone I “walk on water.” But here’s the truth: I didn’t do anything different for her than I do for any of my clients.

What made her experience so positive was that she leaned into the process. She trusted the system I’ve built, and together, we navigated every decision as a team. She became the hero of her own story—not because of me, but because we worked in partnership.

That’s what happens when clients and agents are aligned. The process feels clear, decisions feel confident, and results feel empowering.


Tough Love: What to Look For in the Right Realtor

Too many people choose a realtor based on trust alone. And while trust is absolutely essential, it’s not enough.

Here’s what you should look for:

  1. Trust: Do you feel like this person truly has your back?

  2. Systems and Processes: Do they have proven strategies to protect you from chaos and costly mistakes?

  3. Experience (or Backed Experience): Do they have the knowledge—or a support system behind them—that ensures nothing is left on the table?

If even one of those three pieces is missing, you risk paying the price in money, time, and stress.


The Takeaway

The cost of the wrong realtor isn’t always obvious. You may not realize what you lost until it’s too late. But the right realtor? The right realtor makes you feel clear, supported, and empowered every step of the way—and still puts more money in your pocket when the dust settles.

Because this isn’t just about selling a house. It’s about closing one chapter and opening another with confidence, clarity, and peace.


💛 Ready for Clarity?

Even if you’re not ready to buy or sell yet, let’s talk. The best decisions come from clarity, not guessing. I’ll never pressure you to move before the timing is right for you. Instead, I’ll help you understand your options so when the time does come, you can move forward with confidence.

📩 [Book your strategy session here →]

Kristina Irvine is a top-performing Realtor® and Mortgage Loan Originator with a heart for helping clients align their real estate decisions with their bigger life goals. Recognized for her award-winning marketing strategies and a proven track record of results, Kristina brings clarity, confidence, and care to every transaction. As a Naperville local, dog mom, and community builder, she’s passionate about making the buying and selling process seamless—and ensuring every client feels supported from start to sold.

Kristina Irvine

Kristina Irvine is a top-performing Realtor® and Mortgage Loan Originator with a heart for helping clients align their real estate decisions with their bigger life goals. Recognized for her award-winning marketing strategies and a proven track record of results, Kristina brings clarity, confidence, and care to every transaction. As a Naperville local, dog mom, and community builder, she’s passionate about making the buying and selling process seamless—and ensuring every client feels supported from start to sold.

Back to Blog